Skip to content

Predicting the next Stanley Cup champion and major award winners

Andy Devlin / National Hockey League / Getty

Heading into the 2021 regular season, theScore's Mike Dickson, Josh Gold-Smith, Brandon Maron, John Matisz, Sean O'Leary, Matt Teague, and Josh Wegman make their picks for division champs, major award winners, and the Stanley Cup Final.

North Division

Andre Ringuette/Freestyle Photo / Getty Images Sport / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Oilers
Gold-Smith Jets
Maron Maple Leafs
Matisz Maple Leafs
O'Leary Maple Leafs
Teague Maple Leafs
Wegman Maple Leafs

The Leafs are the betting favorites to win the North, and our voters seem to agree. The team is loaded with high-end talent and fortified its defensive corps, which has been a weakness for years. However, the division will be tightly contested as every club outside of the rebuilding Senators has a real chance to finish No. 1.

East Division

Mark Blinch / National Hockey League / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Islanders
Gold-Smith Capitals
Maron Capitals
Matisz Flyers
O'Leary Penguins
Teague Flyers
Wegman Capitals

The East is the toughest to call. Five teams in the division finished top 11 in the overall standings last season, but the Capitals appear to be the favorites again. Washington has finished atop the Metropolitan in five straight campaigns and has won its division in 10 of 15 seasons since Alex Ovechkin entered the league in 2005-06.

Central Division

Bruce Bennett / Getty Images Sport / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Lightning
Gold-Smith Lightning
Maron Hurricanes
Matisz Hurricanes
O'Leary Lightning
Teague Lightning
Wegman Lightning

The Central is composed of the lonely Red Wings, a bunch of middling clubs, and two clear favorites in last season's champions and the budding Hurricanes. Even without star winger Nikita Kucherov, the Lightning are in good shape to win the division, but Carolina likely won't make it easy for them.

West Division

Bruce Bennett / Getty Images Sport / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Golden Knights
Gold-Smith Avalanche
Maron Golden Knights
Matisz Avalanche
O'Leary Golden Knights
Teague Avalanche
Wegman Avalanche

There's a glaring imbalance in competition in the West, and it'll likely be a three-team race for the division title. Our voters like the Avalanche and Golden Knights, but it wouldn't be a total surprise to see the St. Louis Blues claim the top spot.

'Rocket' Richard Trophy

Mark Blinch / National Hockey League / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Alex Ovechkin
Gold-Smith Auston Matthews
Maron Auston Matthews
Matisz Auston Matthews
O'Leary Auston Matthews
Teague Auston Matthews
Wegman Auston Matthews

Matthews ranks second among all players in goals per game since entering the league in 2016-17, and with David Pastrnak on the shelf to start the year, his window to win the Rocket is that much wider. The 23-year-old also has a dominant track record against several divisional opponents. Matthews has netted 25 goals in 29 games against the Canadiens and Senators, who make up 34% of the Leafs schedule in 2020-21.

Art Ross Trophy

Dave Sandford / National Hockey League / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Connor McDavid
Gold-Smith Connor McDavid
Maron Nathan MacKinnon
Matisz Connor McDavid
O'Leary Nathan MacKinnon
Teague Connor McDavid
Wegman Nathan MacKinnon

Though there are several worthy candidates, our voters believe the Art Ross Trophy race will be between a pair of generational superstars in McDavid and MacKinnon. The former is the unanimous top player in the world, while the latter is right on his heels for the title. Both superstars should amass worthy numbers, but in a league with so much elite talent, there are a handful of others who could take the award as well.

Calder Trophy

Sergei Savostyanov / TASS / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Alexis Lafreniere
Gold-Smith Igor Shesterkin
Maron Igor Shesterkin
Matisz Kirill Kaprizov
O'Leary Kirill Kaprizov
Teague Alexis Lafreniere
Wegman Kirill Kaprizov

Seven Russian-born players have claimed rookie of the year honors, and that number could increase this season. Shesterkin was outstanding in his brief stint in 2019-20, while Kaprizov was arguably the top talent in the world that wasn't playing in the NHL until now. Lafreniere, the 2020 first overall pick, should also rack up his fair share of points while playing within a dynamic top-six forward group for the Rangers.

Vezina Trophy

Andy Devlin / National Hockey League / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Jacob Markstrom
Gold-Smith Andrei Vasilevskiy
Maron Carter Hart
Matisz Carey Price
O'Leary Robin Lehner
Teague Robin Lehner
Wegman Robin Lehner

The Vezina will likely be the most difficult trophy to decide during the shortened season. Most clubs will use a platoon system between the pipes thanks to the condensed schedule, making it hard for some to separate themselves from the pack. Lehner has been arguably the league's best goalie over the past two campaigns, and the Swedish puck-stopper feels due for the award and will play behind the loaded Golden Knights.

Norris Trophy

Dave Sandford / National Hockey League / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Roman Josi
Gold-Smith Victor Hedman
Maron Cale Makar
Matisz Alex Pietrangelo
O'Leary Victor Hedman
Teague Alex Pietrangelo
Wegman Victor Hedman

It's crazy to think Hedman has only earned one Norris Trophy nod. The 30-year-old looks primed to rack up several more awards over the second half of his career. Pietrangelo is the league's best rearguard who has yet to win the trophy and begins his new chapter as the Golden Knights' defensive backbone. Josi is certainly a threat to repeat, and Makar could be in contention after racking up a historic rookie campaign.

Hart Trophy

Bill Smith / National Hockey League / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Connor McDavid
Gold-Smith Nathan MacKinnon
Maron Nathan MacKinnon
Matisz Nathan MacKinnon
O'Leary Nathan MacKinnon
Teague Connor McDavid
Wegman Nathan MacKinnon

As is the case for the Art Ross Trophy, the 2020-21 league MVP is seen as a tight race between McDavid and MacKinnon. MacKinnon, a two-time runner-up for the award, will be the focal point of what many believe is the league's best team in the Avalanche. At the same time, McDavid feels due for his second career Hart after a mid-season injury halted his chances in 2019-20.

Stanley Cup Final

Andy Devlin / National Hockey League / Getty
Editor Pick
Dickson Golden Knights over Islanders
Gold-Smith Avalanche over Lightning
Maron Avalanche over Islanders
Matisz Avalanche over Lightning
O'Leary Maple Leafs over Golden Knights
Teague Golden Knights over Flyers
Wegman Avalanche over Maple Leafs

Most of our voters have the Avalanche capturing their first Stanley Cup in 20 years, with the Golden Knights and Leafs also being selected. The Islanders' defensive approach proved to work in the bubble and have the potential to make a deep run again, while the Lightning are perennially in the mix.

Daily Newsletter

Get the latest trending sports news daily in your inbox